Homologous:
a. Cats and dogs are both considered domesticated animals and they both share a homologous trait with their pelvises and paws. Cats usually have a small stature and are quick on their four legs. Some have tails and some don’t. They adapt quickly to their environment and are a form of a companion for humans. Because of their quickness, light on their four legs, and keen senses, cats are known to hunt, kill, and extinct small prey.
Dogs also move about on four legs. Because dogs are bred for various activities, their sizes, colors, and shapes vary. Humans have also considered them to be companions not only for personal but also for medical reasons such as depression. Dogs have been used for hunting, protection, and farming needs.
b. The pelvis of the cat The pelvis of the dog
Both animal's pelvises share a similar structure where the legs hook, backbone attaches partially, and the birthing canal is in the similar position within the dog and cat.
Paws from a cat and dog are homologous as well because both the dog cat uses the paw to balance, feel, and for stability. Dog’s paws are usually a little rough compared to the cat’s paws whose texture is softer. The dog’s pads are different by way of structure. The cat has 7 pads on front and 5 in the back, whereas a dog has 6 paws with declaws on front paws. The shape of the dog’s paw is oval and cats are round. Cats have retractable claws depending on how the cat feels. The dog claws are always extended. The purposes of the dog’s paws/ claws are to dig, play, and sweat. Cats’ use theirs to climb, play, protect themselves and get food.
DOG CAT
c. Generally, the common ancestor of dog and cat was the Dormaalocyon latouri.
They were known to have lived over 56 thousand years. They were the earliest known carnivores.
They were known to have lived over 56 thousand years. They were the earliest known carnivores.
Analogous:
a. Two different species that portray analogous traits are butterflies and birds.
Butterflies are insects and at the adult stage, their wings are bright, bold, and colorful. Some; however, use their subdued wing color to camouflage them from their predators.
Birds are endothermic vertebrates. They live all over the world and come in a variety of shapes, sizes, and colors. Their wings are used for transportation, warning, others of danger, and mating call.
b. They both have wings. The bird’s wings are attached below the neck and the butterfly’s wings are attached a second and third segment of the thorax. Structurally they are very different, wear as birds have feathers and bones, and butterfly wings are constructed of chitin and thin layers of scales. The similarities of a bird and butterfly are that they both have adapted to life in the air making it their main way of travel. Mating ritual is similar to the way of expanding the wings and sputtering them quickly appeal to the opposite sex in some cases.
c. The common ancestor was hard to find, but I did see it mentioned that they inherited four limbs from a common ancestor. Birds’ ancestor was the Archaeopteryx which was a bird-like dinosaur. The Caddis fly was the ancestor of the butterfly. Both the Caddis fly and the Archaeopteryx derived from a terrestrial organism and is included in the tetrapod because of their four limbs that evolved.
Archaeopteryx/ Caddis fly
Hi April I find it very interesting how the cat and dog have a common ancestor seeing as that most cats are not very fond of dogs and also the other way around. There paws are quite similar even though their claws are mainly being used for different things, I also never noticed how a cats paws can be retracted whenever they don't feel the need to be used anymore, your post was very enjoyable.
ReplyDeleteRaven;
DeleteThank you for your comments regarding dog's and cat's paws. I also never really paid too much attention to the differences between dog and cat paw. I wanted to compare two animals that we see or encounter on a daily basis, something we could look at and start to see the differences and similarities.
Thank you,
April Thomas
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHello April, I found both your homologous and analogous traits to be quite fascinating. I learned so much about all four of these animals. I never realized all the amazing things the paws of dogs and cats could bring such as protecting themselves and digging. I never knew that dogs and cats had a certain number of pads on their paws. It never crossed my mind that the wings of both birds and butterflies were attached to a different part of their body. You did a great job on part c question two as you were able to dig up their own ancestors and found an organism that they both could have related to.
ReplyDeleteHello,
DeleteThank you for your review of my blog. Like a lot of people I love animals, but saw dogs and cats as unrelated, so it was interesting for me to analyze and dig deeper into the background of both cat and dog to uncover similarities and differences of the two species.
Thank you,
April Thomas
Very good and thorough opening descriptions of your species pairings for both your homologous and analogous sections.
ReplyDeleteI'm a little confused as to why you start off talking about the cat and dog pelvis and then switch to paws? The guidelines asked you to choose one trait for comparison. Remember that homologous traits exhibit structural/functional differences resulting from divergent evolution, so the key question from the guidelines is about how these structures differ from each other and why? Explain the functional differences and how they are reflected in their structural differences. Most of the differences you identify in the paws are in the soft tissue and would be difficult to trace in the ancestral line. Perhaps the key structural difference is the issue of climbing, with cats using their paws and claws to climb to escape predation, and dogs missing this ability, but again, it is difficult to see this trait in the fossil record.
It isn't necessary to be too specific on ancestry. The key is that both of these organisms are mammals and possessed many similar structures due to common ancestry. The question that needed to be answered was whether or not the common ancestor possessed the trait in question. Missing that discussion? We need to know that to confirm that the homologous trait (either of them) is the result of common descent (i.e., homologous traits), not independent evolution (i.e., analogous traits).
Good images.
Good discussion of your analogous traits and good focus on the one trait of wings. You do a good job of identifying the structural and functional similarities that were produced from convergent (parallel) evolution.
With regard to ancestry, when we speak of a "common ancestor" that means one ancestor that is shared by both organisms. So identifying separate ancestors for each species isn't identifying the "common ancestor".
It is difficult to guess at what the common ancestor of the bird and butterfly looked like some 100's of millions of years ago... it may have possessed wings or it may not have, but fortunately, we don't need to know that to confirm that these traits are analogous. While it is possible that the butterfly inherited its wings from that common ancestor, what about the bird? We know quite a bit about bird and bird-wing evolution. Birds evolved wings as they split from reptiles, and this occurred long, long after the split with that common ancestor with the butterfly. This means bird wing evolution occurred independently from that common ancestor with the butterfly. That is sufficient to confirm that these are not the product of common descent and are indeed analogous.
Again, good image.
Hello Professor Rodriguez,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your constructive criticism. I appreciate your feedback. One reason for comparing dog and cat was because I love animals and I thought it would be interesting to show the similarities between dog and cat as it pertains to the pelvis. Even though we view dog and cat as opposite, we can see how similar the structure of the pelvises are. I realize this might have not been the best to show.
For the analogous traits I compared the bird and butterfly simply because they were different species. I thought to present the two pictures of Archaeopteryx and Caddis fly. This would show how the ancestors would have looked for each. Even though they are different species, I then went as far trying to go back and find a common ancestor or at least something that could connect them. This is when I found that the only thing connecting the two was the tetrapod. We don't actually know what the terapod looks like, but we do know it was the earliest with species four limbs. I was thinking this is what the assignment called for. Sorry for the confusion.
Thank you,
April Thomas
Thanks for the response.
DeleteWith regard to ancestry for your analogous traits, but they *aren't* connected by tetrapods. Butterflies are in a completely different evolutionary line from the line that produced birds. Fish, birds, amphibians, reptiles and mammals are all in the classificatory phylum of "chordata", or all those with a neural cord to transmit information to the body. This includes those with and without legs. Butterflies are part of the phylum "arthropoda". These lines split off from each other long before there were tetrapods.
Check out this link for more information on this:
http://sciencelearn.org.nz/Contexts/Hidden-Taonga/Science-Ideas-and-Concepts/Classification-system